- Wins Above Replacement - Cubs catcher Wellington Castillo led the team with a WAR of 4.4. WAR is the measurement of how many wins a particular player adds to his team's total above what a replacement player could produce (think AAA or the metaphorical 4-A player). Conversely, Cubs budding superstar Starlin Castro was tied for last on the team, with a WAR of -0.6! Last year, Castro had a WAR of 3.6. In 2011, his WAR was 3.0.
- Runs Batting - Continuing the Cubs dominance at the catching position, 2013 acquisition Dioner Navarro led the club a Rbat of 10. Rbat is the measure of how many runs better or worse than average a player was as a hitter. On the tail end of things, Gold Glove 2nd baseman Darwin Barney pulled up the rear with a Rbat of -33. This is nothing new for Barney. In 2011, he had a Rbat of -8. In 2012, Barney's Rbat was -12. In his defense, Barney's extensive stints on the disabled list didn't help him much.
- Runs from Fielding - The unsung hero of the Chicago Cubs, Wellington Castillo, pops up again here at #3. Castillo led the 2013 Cubs with a Rfield of 19. Rfield is the number of runs better or worse than average a player was for all fielding. Anthony Rizzo came in a close 2nd, with a Rfield 0f 16. Gold Glover Darwin Barney was 3rd at 11. Starlin Castro pulled up the rear, being 8 runs worse than an average player at saving runs with his fielding. Anyone that watched 25% of the Cubs games this year didn't need a stat to know that.
- Runs Better Than Average - RAA is the measure of how many runs better than a league average player this player is. Once again, Wellington Castillo drove the bus for the 2013 Cubs. Castillo led the team with a RAA of 28 (Navarro was 2nd with 11). In their all too familiar positions, Darwin Barney and Starlin Castro occupied the caboose with RAAs of -18 and -22 respectively.
- On-Base + Slugging Percentages - OPS is the combination of a player's on-base percentage and slugging percentage. Dioner Navarro and mid-season pick-up Donnie Murphy led the team with .856 and .849 respectively. Any clue as to what dynamic duo came in last?
- Walks Hits to Innings Pitched - Jake Arrieta, who the Cubs acquired from the Orioles as a part of the Scott Feldman trade, led the Cubs with a 1.12 WHIP. Edwin Jackson, fresh off of a 5-year, $50 million contract with the northsiders, led the team with a 1.46 WHIP. With WHIP, the closer the number is to 1.00, the better.
- Home Runs to Innings Pitched - Conversely, Edwin Jackson gave up the fewest home runs of all eligible Cubs pitchers in 2013. Jackson had a HR/9 of 0.8. On the flip side, Arrieta had a HR/9 of 1.2. What does this mean? While Arrieta didn't walk as many batters as Jackson, he didn't miss many bats within the strike zone.
- Strikeout to Walk Ratio - Matt Garza, who was traded to the Texas Rangers at the deadline, led the Cubs with a SO/BB of 3.10. This means that Garza had 3 strikeouts for every walk that he issued. Jeff Samardzija and former Cub Scott Feldman were round out the top 3. On the other end, Cubs closer Kevin Gregg was close to last with a SO/BB of 1.75. With a nearly 2 to 1 strikeout to walk ratio, it's no wonder the Cubs had significant issues getting the final 3 outs.
- Defensive Runs Saved Above Average - Rdrs is the number of runs above or below average a player was worth based on the number of plays made. of the 4 players that each played over 1000 innings for the Cubs in 2013, Anthony Rizzo led the team with a Rdrs of 16. Darwin Barney was 2nd at a Rdrs of 11. Nate Schierholtz was a perfectly average player, with a Rdrs of 0. Starlin Castro takes his customary position of last, pulling in with a Rdrs of -8.
- Wins Above Average - Cubs All-Star representative Travis Wood led the 2013 Cubs in WAA with a 2.8. Wood was roughly 3-wins better than a minor league call-up. As a comparison, Edwin Jackson was roughly 3-wins worse than a minor league call-up (2.7 to be exact). Jackson and Wood typically pitched back-to-back in the Cubs rotation. Based on the WAA for both pitchers, it's safe to say that whatever positive effect Wood's performance had on the team was immediately extinguished by the performance of Jackson.
So, what did we learn about the 2013 Chicago Cubs from this orgy of statistics and baseball jargon? Well, we learned definitively (if our eyes had not already borne witness) that the Cubs just weren't a very good team. On a general level, the hitters at the top of the order didn't get on base, the big boppers in the middle didn't drive anyone in, fielding up the middle was spotty, and the pitching in both the starting rotation and the bullpen leaves a lot to be desired.
Specifically, there are several areas that Theo, Jed, and the rest of the Cubs brass have to address directly if they want 2014 to begin with more enthusiasm than 2013 ended:
- Who do you want Starlin Castro to be? Do you want a 200-hits per season line drive hitter or do you want a top of the order hitter that takes pitches, draws walks, and steals bases? The Cubs really need to have one vision and one voice on the type of player they want Castro to grow into. Right now, he has so much information in his head, that he's not doing anything well.
- After Samardjiza and Wood...? Who fills out the starting rotation after Jeff Samardjiza and Travis Wood? Jake Arrieta will be in the mix in 2014 due to his late year performance after being recalled from AAA Iowa. However, Arrieta has a history of walking too many batters and giving up some long home runs. Edwin Jackson has had a career marred with the inability to throw strikes at key points and keep his pitch count down. Jackson has a strong arm and typically pitches over 150 innings per year. However, his inconsistency and lack of a breaking ball make him no better than a 4th starter moving forward. Carlos Villanueva filled in admirably as both a starter and a reliever. Though serviceable, you would like to see the Cubs replace Villanueva with a young power arm, moving Carlos to the bullpen where he has thrived in the past.
- Up the Middle! The Cubs have to continue to develop up the middle of the field. Wellington Castillo all but earned the starting job going into 2014 with his standout play behind the plate and at-bat. However, Castillo has been oft injured, so a serviceable back-up would be nice. Castro and Barney are in mirror images of each other. Castro can hit, but can't field. Barney can field, but can't hit. For both players, their weaknesses need to turn into strengths very soon if the Cubs are to compete. Lastly, the Cubs have to solidify center field. There has been veritable revolving door in center since the Cubs traded Marlon Byrd to the Red Sox last year. Ryan Sweeney filled in admirably, posting a .266 average at the plate and a .993 fielding percentage. However, Sweeney's aggressive play make him a candidate for the 15-day disabled list at any time. Sweeney will get a look out of Spring Training, but the Cubs need a young option in the pipeline.
- Enter Sandman - The Cubs have to solidify the back end of their bullpen if they expect to compete for a World Series title. There were some promising signs in 2013. Lefty reliever James Russell led the team with 74 appearances. Pedro Strop, who the Cubs got from the Orioles in the Scott Feldman trade, had 42 strikeouts in 35 innings pitched. Blake Parker and Shawn Camp also get honorable mention recognition for their efforts. However, the Cubs have to make games essentially 6-inning affairs by having shutdown relief pitching in innings 7-9. No where is this need more glaring than in the closer role. Kevin Gregg had a respectable year, recording 33 saves for a last place team. However, Gregg also gave up 53 hits and issued 32 walks in just 62 innings of work. Compare this to Craig Kimbrel, the all world closer for the Atlanta Braves, who had 98 strikeouts and 20 walks in 67 innings.
- Youth Movement - The young players that Cubs organizations has continuously lauded will have to show up, and show up big! Anthony Alomora, Kris Bryant, and other top prospects will have to take their lumps in the big leagues rather than away from the lights and cameras of Wrigleyville. This will give the fans something to hope for while giving the kids the major league at-bats they need to be properly evaluated.